THE ACNA IS IN A MAKE-OR-BREAK MOMENT
An archbishop awaiting a verdict, a deposed bishop in federal court, bishops accused of protecting their own, and one bright spot in Ambridge

COMMENTARY
By David W. Virtue, DD www.virtueonline.org November 17, 2026
The Anglican Church in North America broke away from the Episcopal Church some 15 years ago over authority and sexuality. Now it stands on the edge of a decision about its own future.
Never has the young province looked so fragile. In a single year it has seen its archbishop inhibited and put on trial, a chaplaincy bishop deposed, a diocesan bishop censured, and its College of Bishops accused by its own clergy of negligence. None of this came from Episcopal revisionists. The ACNA did it to itself.
Two Integrities Coming Apart
Women's ordination has simmered on the Anglican stove for years. It now threatens to burn up the "two integrities" settlement that has let those who oppose it and those who support it live together uneasily without rupture.
That settlement is coming apart. Opponents of women's ordination are louder than they have ever been. There is open talk of schism on social media, and it no longer sounds like idle chatter.
The arrangement goes back to the founding. Since 2009 the ACNA Constitution has let each diocese decide whether to ordain women. The College of Bishops reaffirmed this in 2017, while conceding that women priests are "a recent innovation to Apostolic Tradition and Catholic Order." Changing it would take a constitutional amendment passed by the Provincial Assembly. That is a high bar, and it means neither side can win cleanly. So each side keeps fighting.
The signs are everywhere. In February, acting primate Julian Dobbs cancelled a panel on sexism and abuse prevention after the row grew so bitter that it threatened the settlement. Chris Klukas was elected bishop coadjutor of the Great Lakes by a single vote. The Western Gulf Coast spent months deadlocked with the province over its refusal to ordain women priests. Supporters of women's ordination now want the province to stop critics from using the ACNA name online. Opponents say two integrities was never a theology at all, only a truce, and that the truce has run out.
A house divided against itself cannot stand. The ACNA has known this since its birth. It has simply chosen not to look.
The Sword Over Charleston
The denomination's future also waits on a verdict. Archbishop Steve Wood faces allegations of sexual misconduct, abuse of power and plagiarism, and they hang like the sword of Damocles over the whole church.
Wood is the first sitting ACNA archbishop to be tried. He faced three canonical charges: violation of ordination vows, conduct giving just cause for scandal or offense, and sexual immorality. His trial in Charleston ended on September 11 after five days and 38 witnesses. The Court for the Trial of a Bishop has until December 21 to issue its opinion.
He was chosen as a reformer. Whatever the court decides, the province loses. If he is convicted, the archbishop elected to clean house will be removed in disgrace. If he is acquitted, the verdict will land on a laity that has already watched one bishop walk free and drawn its own conclusions. Until then, the church is led by an acting primate and is effectively on hold.
The Chaplaincy and the Courts
At the ecclesiastical level the chaplaincy affair is settled. On September 23 the College of Bishops deposed Derek Jones, former bishop of the Special Jurisdiction of the Armed Forces and Chaplaincy. The College found him guilty of "acts of wickedness, cruelty, and abuse of power." Jones never appeared to defend himself. Five days later a federal judge in South Carolina dismissed the JAFC lawsuit against the province, ruling that the civil courts could not settle what is at heart a church dispute.
The civil courts are not finished with the ACNA, though. Bishop Dobbs's federal defamation suit against Jones in the Northern District of Alabama is still open. Dobbs says Jones falsely accused him of "absconding" with about $48,000 in chaplaincy funds while Dobbs led CANA. Jones, now leading his breakaway Anglican Reformed Catholic Church, has moved to dismiss. Neither man has backed down. Clergy are publicly asking why a bishop is taking another bishop to secular court when 1 Corinthians 6 forbids it and the ACNA's own canons provide a forum for exactly this kind of dispute. Meanwhile, legal bills keep running up for a province whose cash reserves are already thin.
A Chaplain Who Would Not Be Silenced
Beneath the surface, accounts of Jones's alleged abuse of several priests keep coming out. The most vocal of these priests is the Rev. Lance Lormand.
Lormand is an AMiA priest and an active-duty Air Force chaplain. He is a complainant in the case against Jones, and he has refused to go away quietly. According to Lormand, in December 2023 Jones sent him a backdated, uncanonical Letter of Godly Admonition and tried to discipline, inhibit and defrock him. Jones was not his bishop and not his endorser. Lormand says Jones threatened to damage him with the Air Force's Chief of Chaplains, which would have ended his career. He says his family now has security cameras at their home.
Lormand's real target, though, is the College. In a sworn affidavit published in parts on his Substack, and in a statement to the College of Bishops on November 5, he names the bishops he says failed him. He says Foley Beach recused himself in 2021 instead of acting, and ignored urgent emails in 2023. He says Bishop Ray Sutton took Jones's side in a 2021 case against another chaplain without ever speaking to that chaplain. He says Wood chose to handle Jones "pastorally." And he says Dobbs did not answer his 2023 plea for help. Lormand also reports that one bishop told him he had emails warning Beach about Jones going back to 2014.
Lormand says Jones was a known quantity. What grieves him more is the bishops who looked away. He calls the College "the party at fault" and asks for structural repentance, not private apologies. His demands are concrete: presentments against the bishops he names, an end to NDAs and gag orders on complainants, and Sutton's resignation.
These are allegations, and the bishops named are entitled to answer them. But Lormand is no longer alone. This month a Reformed Episcopal missionary publicly accused Bishop Sutton of negligence in a separate dispute and said Lormand's account "resonated deeply" with his own family's experience. In July, chaplains filed complaints against Beach, Sutton and Wood alleging habitual neglect of duty. Those complaints have not been publicly resolved.
L'Affaire Ruch
The Ruch affair will not go away. In December 2025 Bishop Stewart Ruch of the Upper Midwest was acquitted on all charges over his handling of the Mark Rivera child-abuse case, six and a half years after a nine-year-old girl first disclosed her abuse. The trial was held in private. The court's 71-page order found that "no evidence demonstrated that Bishop Ruch willfully contravened canonical authority."
Ruch's supporters felt vindicated, and his family went through years of hell. But the verdict has not played well with lay people. Many of them believe he was given a pass when he should have been shown the door. More than 200 people signed a letter calling for an investigation of the trial itself. Survivors said the verdict confirmed their fear that bishops get a free pass. Rivera, meanwhile, is serving 15 years in prison. A child was abused, the abuser was convicted, and no one in authority was found to bear any responsibility. Ordinary churchgoers are not stupid. They can count.
Circling the Wagons
More and more, the ACNA's safeguarding looks like bishops circling the wagons around their own instead of caring for the sheep.
Look at the pattern. In November 2025 the chaplains told the College in an open letter that it had been "willfully ignorant, grossly incompetent, and negligent." Ruch was acquitted after a secret trial. Todd Atkinson was deposed, but only after years of delay. The College did depose Jones in September, and in doing so it confessed its own silence. The confession was welcome, but it came about a decade late. In every case the canons favor the accused bishop, the process runs on for years, and the victim waits.
The ACNA's structure makes this worse. The province is decentralized and gives bishops great autonomy. The bishops judge one another, sit on one another's courts and attend one another's consecrations. When the people who are supposed to hold bishops accountable are their friends, accountability becomes a matter of etiquette.
To be fair, there are signs of reform. A complete rewrite of Title IV is under way. In June the College adopted a customary setting minimum vetting standards for episcopal elections, so that past problems come to light before a man is consecrated, not after. These are real steps. But a customary is only paper. The laity will believe in reform when a bishop who protected an abuser actually pays a price for it.
A Bottom-Smacking Moment
Bishop Chip Edgar's misstep with a female Episcopal bishop has been resolved. On August 18 he joined Bishop Ruth Woodliff-Stanley of the Episcopal Diocese of South Carolina to dedicate St. Timothy's Chapel at Porter-Gaud School in Charleston, at a service that included a Eucharist. The photographs set off an uproar. Edgar apologized ("where my actions have offended, forgive me"), accepted a presentment without a trial, and in September received a censure, the lightest penalty available, with no restrictions on his ministry.
It was a bottom-smacking moment. It was also a reminder of how fragile the relationship between TEC and the ACNA still is, and how little the ACNA has done to define it. South Carolina went through years of property litigation with the Episcopal Church. One photograph reopened every wound. The ACNA says communion with TEC is broken, but it has never said in practice what that means at a school chapel, a funeral or an ecumenical service. Until it does, there will be more Porter-Gauds.
By the Numbers
The ACNA's growth story has held up, but it is starting to slow.
For three years after COVID, the province's annual attendance growth ran into double digits, including 13.4 percent in 2024. That pace is over. Diocesan data released in late October shows a 2.55 percent rise in churchwide Average Principal Sunday Attendance in 2025, from 96,009 in 2024 to 98,514. That still puts the ACNA in the small group of U.S. denominations, including the PCA and the Assemblies of God, that report annual growth of 2–3 percent. In an age of shrinking churches that is no small thing. But it is a long way down from double digits.
The fine print is less encouraging. In June the province announced 2025 attendance of 98,434, up just 1.5 percent; the 2024 baseline was later revised down to 96,009, which makes the gain look bigger. Membership was revised too. It rose from 128,161 to 129,997, about 1.4 percent, but the 2024 figure was originally reported as 130,111. If last year's membership number had stood, the province would be reporting a decline.
The parish count is going the wrong way. Congregations fell from 1,027 to 1,004, a net loss of 23, after a net gain of 14 the year before. The province has offered no explanation, and its new impact report skips over the drop. Church planting has also slowed. The ACNA's own Mission Index counts 445 new parishes in 15 years, but says plants have slowed over the past two years.
The ACNA is also a church of small congregations. Seventy-three percent average fewer than 100 people, and 48 percent average 50 or fewer. Spread across 1,004 parishes, the province averages about 98 people per Sunday. Many of these are fragile congregations that cannot survive the loss of one rector, one large family or one scandal.
Look at where the losses fell. The Anglican Diocese of South Carolina, the province's flagship, dropped from 8,858 to 8,133, a loss of 725, the largest drop in the ACNA. The Western Gulf Coast, the diocese deadlocked over women's ordination, fell from 1,621 to 1,508. These 2025 figures predate the Porter-Gaud affair and the Wood trial. What 2026 will show, with an archbishop on trial and a College of Bishops under fire, nobody yet knows.
There is real good news too. Baptisms reached 4,158 in 2025, up 30 percent since 2022, and confirmations reached 4,285, up 40 percent. In the South, the Rockies and Christ Our Hope, people are coming to Christ, being baptized and joining the church. The question is whether the scandals at the top will undo the work being done in the pews.
The Bright Spot in Ambridge
The one bright spot is Trinity Anglican Seminary, which fully supports the ACNA and is training its next generation of ordinands.
The Very Rev. Canon Dr. Bryan Hollon, the dean and president, is a brilliant and resourceful theologian and a capable administrator, and he is holding down the fort at a difficult moment. Hollon holds a Ph.D. from Baylor and taught theology at Malone University for sixteen years before becoming Trinity's eighth dean in 2022. Under him the seminary, founded fifty years ago to renew the Episcopal Church from within, has committed itself unequivocally to the ACNA. Last December it received a grant of nearly $10 million from Lilly Endowment to create an Anglican Formation Network. It has expanded its programs and is forming priests rooted in Scripture and the classical Anglican tradition.
His support matters enormously right now. Bishops come and go, and some, it turns out, go in disgrace. A seminary shapes what a church will be in thirty years. If the ACNA survives this season, it will be partly because places like Trinity kept turning out priests who know what they believe and why.
Make or Break
The ACNA was born claiming to be the faithful remnant. Its founders left the Episcopal Church saying it had abandoned Scripture, ignored its own canons and put institutional self-protection ahead of truth. Fifteen years later the province faces those same charges, this time from its own chaplains, survivors and lay people.
So far, the ACNA's orthodoxy is intact. Its credibility is not. Its leaders can repent publicly, specifically and structurally. Or they can circle the wagons and hope the faithful stop asking questions.
The faithful are not going to stop asking.
David W. Virtue, DD, is founder and managing editor of VirtueOnline. His writings can be found at www.virtueonline.org, where you can subscribe to receive his free biweekly VIEWPOINTS. His Substack on the Middle East can be viewed here: davidvirtue2.substack.com




I think the best thing for all would be if Steve Wood resigned. Even if he is acquited, he lost credibility. It wouldn`t be easy to solve the women`s ordination question. A good alternative would be the diaconate. I myself once supported women`s ordination, but now that I fully understand the question I am totally against it.