Listening: The Great Theological Cop-Out

COMMENTARY
By David W. Virtue, DD www.virtueonline.org November 17, 2026
When in doubt, listen. It has become the mantra of the theological left whenever it is caught between what Scripture plainly says and what the culture plainly wants.
It is worth noticing where the word came from. At Lambeth 1998, Resolution I.10 passed overwhelmingly. It declared homosexual practice incompatible with Scripture and said the bishops could not advise the blessing of same-sex unions or the ordination of people in such unions. Tucked inside that resolution was a commitment to “listen to the experience of homosexual persons.” It was offered as a pastoral courtesy. Within a few years it had become a weapon. The one clause the revisionists liked was turned against the rest of the resolution, and soon nobody spoke of anything else.
The Griswold Method
No one used the word more skillfully than the late Presiding Bishop Frank Griswold. He was a gifted man, liturgically sensitive, softly spoken and spiritually fluent, and he used that gift to carry homosexuality into the heart of the Episcopal Church. Griswold seldom argued. He invited. He pleaded with all sides to listen to the stories of gay and lesbian Episcopalians who were demanding full inclusion at every level of the church. He spoke of truth as something still unfolding and of a “mind of Christ” that would show itself if only we would stay at the table long enough.
Then, in November 2003, he laid hands on Gene Robinson.
Listening never meant finding the truth about anything. It was not built for that. It was never meant to defend Scripture or to give orthodox believers a fair hearing. It was designed to appease, to soften, and finally to silence objectors.
The process was simple. Hear the stories of aggrieved gay Episcopalians. Feel their pain. Agree that the church had been homophobic. Repent of it, and reverse course.
Tactically Brilliant
Give credit where it is due: as tactics go, it was brilliant.
It made orthodox Anglicans feel guilty for not listening, as though “Thus saith the Lord” were a failure of compassion rather than an act of obedience. It turned the argument from Scripture into an argument about feelings, and you cannot cross-examine a feeling. It gave the floor to Gene Robinson, whose story was the only one that really counted. It won the sympathy of bishops who had seldom read the Bible closely and never taken it seriously. It invited them to feel Gene’s pain of rejection, and then to vote for a sexual ethic the church had never once embraced in two thousand years.
Notice the asymmetry. Nobody was ever asked to “listen” to the man who had left the gay life for Christ, to the faithful celibate who chose obedience over appetite, or to the African bishop whose people were dying for the faith. Those stories were inconvenient. Listening was always one-way traffic.
The church had never blessed fornication. It had never blessed adultery. Now it was being asked, in fact told, to bless a behavior Scripture expressly forbids. And the question was never “What does God say?” It was “How does this make you feel?”
Where Listening Led
For the Episcopal Church, the destination was always clear even when the road was dressed up as a pilgrimage. Robinson in 2003. Rites for blessing same-sex unions in 2012. Same-sex marriage in 2015. Then Resolution B012 in 2018, which took away a diocesan bishop’s right to keep same-sex marriage out of his own diocese.
Just ask Bishop Bill Love of Albany. He did what every Episcopal bishop had once vowed to do: guard the faith. For that he was brought up under Title IV, found to have violated the canons, and forced from his see. So much for listening. Once the revisionists had the votes, the listening stopped. Love’s conscience, his diocese and his reading of Scripture got no hearing at all. Listening is something the orthodox owe the progressives. It is never owed in the other direction.
Listening was never meant to find the truth. It was meant to amplify one grievance, berate the opposition, stifle dissent, and declare victory.
Rowan Williams and the Communion
The other great voice for listening was Archbishop of Canterbury Rowan Williams. He pleaded with the primates of the Global South to listen to Western Anglicans, who were supposedly more enlightened about sexuality.
Williams was the classic fence-sitter. Back in 1989, in his lecture “The Body’s Grace,” he had argued for the moral seriousness of committed same-sex relationships. His later private correspondence, published during his archbishopric, showed that he had not changed his mind. Yet from the chair of Augustine he publicly upheld Lambeth I.10. He believed one thing and enforced another, and he asked everyone else to keep listening while he made up his mind in public.
So, the machinery of listening rolled on. The Windsor Report came in 2004. The primates met at Dromantine in 2005 and asked for a formal “Listening Process.” The Anglican Consultative Council put it in place that year. At Lambeth 2008, resolutions gave way to indaba groups, African-style conversation circles where everyone talked, nobody decided, and nothing was voted on. Then came “Continuing Indaba.” The Church of England produced its own version, with the Pilling Report, the “Shared Conversations,” and finally Living in Love and Faith. Years of listening ended exactly where everyone knew it would, with the Prayers of Love and Faith in 2023.
The Global South listened, and to their great credit they heard. They heard the Western stories, the Western theology and the Western money, and they said no. More than two hundred bishops stayed away from Lambeth 2008 and went to Jerusalem for GAFCON instead. I was there. In 2023 the GSFA primates declared they could no longer recognize the Archbishop of Canterbury as first among equals.
Williams failed. His failure tore the Communion apart, and, like Dumpty, it will never be put back together as it was.
What Biblical Listening Actually Is
Here is the irony. Scripture is full of listening, but it is never this kind.
“Hear, O Israel: The Lord our God, the Lord is one.” The Shema does not ask Israel to listen to its own experience. It asks Israel to listen to God. “Speak, Lord, for your servant is listening,” said the boy Samuel, not “Speak, Eli, and tell me how you feel.” Faith, says Paul, comes by hearing, and hearing by the word of God. Our Lord said, “My sheep hear my voice.” He said “He who has ears to hear, let him hear” about his own words, not about the spirit of the age.
The first act of “listening” in the Bible ended in disaster. “Because you have listened to the voice of your wife,” God told Adam, “and have eaten of the tree…” Eve had listened to the serpent, who asked a question too: “Did God really say…?” That is still the question behind every listening process. It sounds humble and it is lethal.
My mentor John Stott spoke of “double listening”: listening to the Word and to the world. But Stott was clear about what came first. We listen to the world so that we understand it well enough to address it with the Word. We never listen so that the world can sit in judgment on the Word. The Episcopal Church and the Church of England turned Stott’s formula upside down. They listened to the world, then reread the Word until it agreed.
James tells us to be “quick to hear, slow to speak.” The revisionists quote it often. They are less fond of the rest of that letter, which tells us to be doers of the word and not hearers only.
The Cost of the Cop-Out
Listening is a virtue. Listening as a substitute for obedience is a vice, and a cowardly one. It lets a bishop dodge the hard duty of saying “This is what the Lord says,” while still feeling like the most compassionate man in the room.
The fruit is plain to see. Episcopal Sunday attendance has collapsed, and so has the Communion. The listeners have been left talking mostly to themselves in emptying cathedrals, while the churches that kept listening to Scripture fill up in Lagos, Kampala, Nairobi and Singapore.
The Episcopal Church listened to everyone but God. Now, increasingly, nobody is listening to the Episcopal Church.
David W. Virtue, DD, is founder and managing editor of VirtueOnline. His writings can be found at www.virtueonline.org, where you can subscribe to receive his free biweekly VIEWPOINTS. His Substack on the Middle East can be viewed here: davidvirtue2.substack.com




Comments