New bishop holds firm to incremental reform in Church

By Toby Cohen

http://www.religiousintelligence.org/

June 10th, 2010

Episcopal vacancies are opening up across the Church, and in the next few years the House of Bishops could have a very different complexion. With the Church teetering on the brink of some major changes, there is particular curiosity about the mentality of the new men under the mitres.

The Assistant Area Dean of Southampton, the Rev Canon Geoffrey Annas, was announced last week as the next Bishop of Stafford. As his new Diocesan Bishop, the Rt Rev John Gledhill, makes clear, Canon Annas has just the right sort of credentials: He has won the respect of the whole community and many attribute a drop in serious crime to the neighbourliness and vision of St Christopher’s [Thornhill, where he was made vicar in ‘94].He has overseen the establishment of the Southampton Street Pastors’ Scheme and a new Academy school, under the auspices of the Diocese and Oasis Trust. More recently he has been assistant Area Dean in the large Southampton Deanery, caring for clergy and lay leaders.

Canon Annas’ expertise in important frontline Church initiatives qualifies him well for service in any part of the organisation, as he acknowledges in an interview during his return to Lichfield last week, 25 years after his only previous visit there on a diocesan retreat.

My background has obviously been very much in ministry in the urban setting, but I spend a lot of time today with people in the rural setting and that’s been fascinating. The links between the two [are fascinating] as well. There’s not as much diversity between the two as people make out.

He will miss the people he has worked with in Southampton, but is confident in their ability to carry on the good work’ he is aware of great achievements being made in Lichfield, but is confident in the call of God and the help of his supportive team.

So far there is little to distinguish him from the other humble and enthused servants of the Church who have been selected for elevation. But Canon Annas himself detects a shift: There’s a general change in culture at the moment. It’s not just in the Church, I think the result of the General Election is an indication that people generally are looking now more towards consensual ways forward rather than being competitive all the time.

We sometimes make the mistake that everyone wants something new but there’s a lot that’s good about the traditional ways we’ve always done things and it’s just about bringing the two together really, which is what I meant by the consensual thing.

That might not be the change others in the Church are talking about. And if they are talking about it at Synod this summer, they may have to look hard to find that spirit of consensus which the Archbishop of Canterbury was pleading for in February.

So how has that culture of consensus affected Canon Annas’ own stance on disputed issues?

I haven’t compromised at all, in that I am totally supportive of women bishops and I very much value the ministry of my female colleagues. And I look forward to the time when they exercise Episcopal ministry as well.

Although I’m 100 per cent behind the ordination of women to the episcopate, I’m also incredibly sensitive to those who find it difficult, and this is again where the consensual thing comes in. The last thing that I want is for anybody to feel alienated, I think the Church should be inclusive and so I think we have to work within that.

So perhaps traditionalists needn’t be too worried just yet. The new Bishop of Stafford joins the large gang of Church ‘liberals’ who believe in incremental development rather than table-turning reform. He plays the same line on gays: My feelings about openly gay clergy - I personally have no issues with that at all, but I think again like the ordination of women to the episcopate it’s something where there needs to be enormous sensitivity.

I’m not somebody who will overthrow rules and regulations for the sake of it, because I think if you do that you get chaos and anarchy, but I am somebody who will work to build a consensus to change rules and regulations and I would hope that in the future at some point people could be allowed to be true to themselves.

It is not a sin to be a homosexual, and that is very much the teaching of the Church of England. What the Church does teach is that actually whether you’re heterosexual or gay, outside of a committed married relationship, there should be no physical sexual activity.

Well, as you realise, unless you’re saying to me that gay people should marry, which I personally wouldn’t agree with, you’re going to deprive gay people of that possibility of having a physical relationship, which to my mind seems contrary to what being in a creative loving relationship is all about.

This is where traditionalists and liberals alike may wish to interject. No one is asking him to overthrow rules and regulations for the sake of it. Liberal society is asking him to do it, primarily, for the sake of those still suffering at the sharp end of our culture’s homophobic heritage. The Church might not like being seen as the great curator of that heritage, but at least this shows that some of that society has not laughed and walked away.

Traditionalists are asking why, if he feels women are entitled to be bishops and people who are gay entitled to physical relationships without being excluded, he doesn’t take a stand and openly challenge the Church, instead of sneakily undermining it.

Talk about a poisoned chalice. At least he is in good company as he steps out on to this tightrope, on which the Archbishop of Canterbury is another balanced with his crosier. Canon Annas is steeled to face these challenges while preserving strength to concentrate on the issues most dear to him, such as climate change and the damage of the recession.

On one line he is united with a great many in the Church: All too often newspapers are focussing on these two particular issues, when there are so many issues... A lot of the Church’s agenda is dictated by the media so I encourage you and urge you to start broadening it a bit. Who can blame him?

2003 YEAR IN REVIEW - Part One

I sense an impending train wreck the size of which this part of the Anglican Communion has not seen. The Rt. Rev. Peter Beckwith, Bishop of Springfield

THE YEAR IN REVIEW (Part 1)

LATE BREAKING FIGURES FROM ANGLICAN MAINSTREAM

www.anglican-mainstream.net/index2.htm

Support So Far 13,628,200 Including:

Most Revd Livingstone Mpalanyi-Nkoyoyo and the Church of the Uganda Archbishop Yong Ping Chung and the Province of South East Asia Presiding Bishop Greg Venables, Southern Cone Archbishop Fidelis Dirokpa and the Province of the Congo Rt Rev Dr Bernard Malango and the Province of Central Africa Most Rev Benjamin M Nzimbi and the Anglican Church of Kenya

Rt Rev Peter John Lee and Bishops Council, Diocese of Christ the King, CPSA

Rt Rev Jack Iker and Diocese of Fort Worth

Rt Rev Stephen K Nyorsok and Diocese of Kitale Kenya

Rt Rev Dr Glenn N Davies, North Sydney

Rt Rev Stephen Hale, Melbourne

Rt Rev Colin Bazley, Former Primate Southern Cone

Rev Louis Tsui &amp’ Eastern Kowloon

Rt Rev John Jun’ichiro Furumoto, Diocese of Kobe, Japan

Canon David Anderson (AAC)

David Peterson, Principal, Oak Hill College

Peter C Moore, Trinity Episcopal School for Ministry

Rev Ulric Gerry University of Dar Es Salaam, Tanzania

Evangelical Fellowship of Irish Clergy

Rev Jude Edomwonyi, St Augustine, Bahamas

Preb Richard Bewes and All Souls Langham Place, London

Rev Susan H Crane and Iglesia de San Mat=EDas, Tennessee

Rev Vincent Rakotoarisoa, St Peter’s Ambanidia, Antananarivo, Madagascar

Rev Ed Hird and St Simon’s, New Westminster

Rev Paul Harcourt and All Saints Woodford Wells, Chelmsford

Holy Spirit Anglican Church, Recife, Brazil

Church of the Redeemer, South West Florida

Rev Joanne Beacon and Humboldt Parish Saskatoon

4.013 individuals

11,665 in 3,192 families

69,922 in 249 parishes and organisations

198,600 in 8 dioceses

13,334,000 in 5 provinces

As of 12:00 GMT, 29/12/03

New Hampshire Consecration Attending Bishops Primates

The Most Rev. Frank T. Griswold Presiding Bishop of the Episcopal Church and Chief Consecrator

The Most Rev. Martin De Jesus Barahona Primate of the Province of Central America and Bishop of El Salvador

International

Bishop Krister Stendahl, Lutheran Church of Sweden, Bishop Emeritus of

Stockholm and Co-consecrator

The Rt. Rev. Bruce Stavert, Bishop of Quebec (Anglican Church of Canada)

The Rt. Rev. Michael Ingham, Bishop of New Westminster (Anglican Church of

Canada)

Episcopal Diocesan Bishops

The Rt. Rev. Joe Burnett, Bishop of Nebraska

The Rt. Rev. John B. Chane, Bishop of Washington

The Rt. Rev. George Councell, Bishop of New Jersey

The Rt. Rev. Thomas Ely, Bishop of Vermont

The Rt. Rev. James J. Jelinek, Bishop of Minnesota

The Rt. Rev. Chilton Knudsen, Bishop of Maine and co-consecrator

The Rt. Rev. James A. Kelsey, Bishop of Northern Michigan

The Rt. Rev. Jack=A0 M. McKelvey, Bishop of Rochester

The Rt. Rev. M. Thomas Shaw, SSJE, Bishop of Massachusetts

The Rt. Rev. Andrew D. Smith, Bishop of Connecticut

The Rt. Rev. Douglas Theuner, Bishop of New Hampshire

The Rt. Rev. Orris G. Walker, Jr., Bishop of Long Island Suffragan, assisting and retired Episcopal Bishops

The Rt. Rev. Craig Anderson, Bishop of South Dakota (retired)

The Rt. Rev. G. P. Mellick Belshaw, Bishop of New Jersey (retired)

The Most Rev. Edmond L. Browning, retired Presiding Bishop and co-consecrator

The Rt. Rev. Roy F. Cederholm, Bishop Suffragan of Massachusetts

The Rt. Rev. Otis Charles, Bishop of Utah (retired)

The Rt. Rev. Steven Charleston, Bishop of Alaska (resigned)

The Rt. Rev. James E. Curry, Bishop Suffragan of Connecticut

The Rt. Rev. Jane H. Dixon, Bishop Suffragan of Washington (retired)

The Rt. Rev. Herbert A. Donovan, Jr., Bishop of Arkansas (retired) and

co-consecrator

The Rt. Rev. A. Theodore Eastman, Bishop of Maryland (retired) and

co-consecrator

The Rt. Rev. Gayle E. Harris, Bishop Suffragan of Massachusetts

The Rt. Rev. Barbara C. Harris, Bishop Suffragan of Massachusetts (retired)

and co-consecrator

The Rt. Rev. Donald P. Hart, Assistant Bishop of Southern Virginia

The Rt. Rev. Harold A. Hopkins, Bishop of North Dakota (retired)

The Rt. Rev. George N. Hunt III, Bishop of Rhode Island (retired)

The Rt. Rev. Edward W. Jones, Bishop of Indianapolis (retired)

The Rt. Rev. H. Coleman McGehee, Jr., Bishop of Michigan (retired)

The Rt. Rev. Wilfrido Ramos-Orench, Bishop Suffragaon of Connecticut

The Rt. Rev. Walter C. Righter, Bishop of Iowa (retired)

The Rt. Rev. Hays H. Rockwell, Bishop of Missouri (retired)

The Rt. Rev. Catherine Roskam, Bishop Suffragan of New York

The Rt. Rev. Bennett J. Sims, Bishop of Atlanta (retired)

The Rt. Rev. Philip A. Smith, Bishop of New Hampshire (retired)

The Rt. Rev. Daniel L. Swenson, Bishop of Vermont (retired)

The Rt. Rev. Arthur Walmsley, Bishop of Connecticut (retired)

The Rt. Rev. O’Kelley Whitaker, Bishop of Central New York (retired)

The Rt. Rev. R. Stewart Wood, Jr., Bishop of Michigan (retired)

Attending but not participating

The Rt. Rev. Michael Mayes of Limerick and Killaloe (Church of Ireland)

Dissenting Bishops

The Episcopal Church

Diocesan Bishops

The Rt. Rev. Keith Ackerman, Bishop of Quincy

The Rt. Rev. James Adams, Bishop of Western Kansas

The Rt. Rev. Peter Beckwith, Bishop of Springfield

The Rt. Rev. Robert Duncan, Bishop of Pittsburgh

The Rt. Rev. Bertram N. Herlong, Bishop of Tennessee

The Rt. Rev. Daniel Herzog, Bishop of Albany

The Rt. Rev. John W. Howe, Bishop of Central Florida

The Rt. Rev. Gethin Hughes, Bishop of San Diego

The Rt. Rev. Jack Iker, Bishop of Fort Worth

The Rt. Rev. Russell E. Jacobus, Bishop of Fond du Lac

The Rt. Rev. Stephen Jecko, Bishop of Florida

The Rt. Rev. Terrence Kelshaw, Bishop of Rio Grande

The Rt. Rev. John Lipscomb, Bishop of Southwest Florida

The Rt. Rev. Edward Salmon, Bishop of South Carolina

The Rt. Rev. John-David Schofield, Bishop of San Joaquin

The Rt. Rev. James Stanton, Bishop of Dallas

Suffragan, assisting and/or retired

The Rt. Rev. C. FitzSimons Allison, Bishop of South Carolina (retired)

The Rt. Rev. David Bena, Bishop Suffragan of Albany

The Rt. Rev. Clarence Pope, Bishop of Fort Worth (retired)

The Rt. Rev. C. William Frey, Bishop of Colorado (retired)

The Rt. Rev. Philip Elder, Bishop Suffragan of Guyana (retired)

The Rt. Rev. Hugo Pina-Lopez, Assisting Bishop of Central Florida

The Rt. Rev. Edward MacBurney, Bishop of Quincy (retired)

The Rt. Rev. Earl McArthur, Bishop Suffragan of West Texas (retired)

The Rt. Rev. Donald Parsons, Bishop of Quincy (retired)

The Rt. Rev. Henry Scriven, Assistant Bishop of Pittsburgh

The Rt. Rev. William Wantland, Bishop of Eau Claire (retired)

END