All Things Work Together for Good: What Romans 8:28 Actually Promises
The Christian hope is not that every sorrow will be explained, but that no sorrow can defeat the purposes of God.
There are few passages of Scripture more frequently quoted in times of suffering than Romans 8:28. It appears on sympathy cards, in funeral homilies, and in conversations with those who have experienced tragedy. Christians repeat it to one another as an assurance that, whatever has happened, God will somehow make everything right.
Yet there is a danger in our familiarity with this verse. We may become so accustomed to its comforting words that we cease to consider precisely what St. Paul is promising.
The Apostle writes:
“And we know that all things work together for good to those who love God, to those who are the called according to His purpose.” — Romans 8:28 (NKJV)
Notice what Paul does not say.
He does not say that all things are good. He does not say that every tragedy conceals a blessing that will eventually become apparent. He does not even promise that every painful experience will produce some identifiable benefit during our earthly lives.
He says that all things work together for good.
The distinction is not merely grammatical. It is theological, and it is of enormous importance to anyone who has ever stood beside a hospital bed, attended the burial of a child, or attempted to comfort someone whose life has been shattered by circumstances beyond his control.
The Christian promise is not that suffering will always make sense. It is that suffering cannot defeat God.
The Context We Too Often Forget
Romans 8:28 does not appear in a discussion of earthly prosperity or personal achievement. It appears in the midst of one of the most profound treatments of suffering in the New Testament.
Paul begins this portion of his argument with a remarkable declaration:
“For I consider that the sufferings of this present time are not worthy to be compared with the glory which shall be revealed in us.” — Romans 8:18 (NKJV)
The Apostle does not deny the reality of suffering. Indeed, he proceeds to describe a creation groaning under the consequences of the Fall. The whole created order, he tells us, awaits its deliverance from corruption.
Nor are Christians exempt from this condition. We ourselves groan, awaiting the redemption of our bodies. Even our prayers are marked by weakness, for, as Paul explains in verse 26, we do not always know what we ought to pray for.
It is into this world of groaning, weakness, and uncertainty that Paul speaks the words of verse 28.
This is important.
Romans 8:28 is not addressed to people who have escaped suffering. It is addressed to those who remain within it.
The Christian does not possess a divine exemption from the sorrows of a fallen world. He becomes ill. He suffers disappointment. He encounters betrayal and injustice. He watches those he loves grow old and die. Eventually, unless Christ returns first, he too must pass through the grave.
And yet Paul declares that the purposes of God remain secure.
How can he make such a claim?
Because the Apostle is not looking merely at the circumstances of this present life. He is looking toward eternity.
What Does Paul Mean by Good?
The Greek expression at the heart of Romans 8:28 is panta synergei eis agathon — all things work together for good.
The verb synergei carries the sense of working together or contributing toward a common result. It is the source of our English word synergy.
But the crucial question is not simply how these things work together.
It is what Paul means by good.
We frequently supply our own definition. We imagine that the good must be a favorable outcome: recovery from illness, restoration of a broken relationship, financial security after hardship, or some unexpected opportunity arising from disappointment.
Certainly, God may bring such blessings out of adversity. His providence operates within the ordinary circumstances of human life, and Christians can testify to countless occasions when suffering was followed by blessings they had never anticipated.
But is that what Paul is promising?
The answer lies in the following verse:
“For whom He foreknew, He also predestined to be conformed to the image of His Son, that He might be the firstborn among many brethren.” — Romans 8:29 (NKJV)
Here the Apostle identifies the purpose toward which God is working.
It is not necessarily our prosperity, our comfort, or even our continued earthly existence.
It is our conformity to Jesus Christ.
This is the good toward which divine providence directs the lives of those who belong to God.
We are being formed into the likeness of the Son, prepared for the glory that shall be revealed, and brought toward the final redemption of which Paul has already spoken.
The promise is therefore considerably greater than the assurance that our immediate circumstances will improve.
It is the assurance that God’s saving purpose will not fail.
The Cross: Where Evil Met the Providence of God
If we wish to understand how God can bring good out of evil without making evil itself good, we need look no further than Calvary.
Consider the Crucifixion.
Judas betrayed an innocent man. The religious authorities conspired against Him. Pontius Pilate condemned a man whom he knew to be innocent. Roman soldiers mocked, scourged, and crucified the Lord of Glory.
These actions were wicked.
They were not rendered righteous by their eventual consequences. Judas did not become virtuous because his betrayal contributed to the events of Good Friday. Pilate’s injustice did not cease to be injustice because the death of Christ accomplished the redemption of mankind.
And yet, through these very events, God brought about the salvation of the world.
The Cross stands as the supreme demonstration that human wickedness cannot frustrate divine providence.
Indeed, the Christian faith proclaims something even more astonishing: the very instrument of Christ’s humiliation became the sign of His victory.
The Cross was not good because cruelty is good. It was good because God, in His infinite wisdom and mercy, accomplished through it what sinful men could neither foresee nor comprehend.
This distinction is essential.
To say that God can bring good out of evil is not to say that God approves of evil. Nor does His sovereignty absolve human beings of responsibility for their actions.
The same principle appears centuries earlier in the words of Joseph to his brothers:
“But as for you, you meant evil against me; but God meant it for good, in order to bring it about as it is this day, to save many people alive.” — Genesis 50:20 (NKJV)
Joseph does not excuse their betrayal. He identifies their intention as evil.
But he recognizes that their intentions were not the final authority governing his life.
God was.
Providence Is Not Fatalism
There is a temptation, particularly when discussing divine sovereignty, to slip into a form of religious fatalism.
We hear Christians say, “Everything happens for a reason.”
Sometimes this is offered as an expression of confidence in God’s providence. But the statement can also conceal a dangerous assumption: that every event must be understood as something God positively desired to occur.
Such reasoning confuses God’s permission of evil with His approval of it.
God forbids murder. He condemns oppression. He commands justice and mercy. It would be a grave theological error to suggest that these evils become expressions of His moral will simply because He permits them within His creation.
The distinction between God’s sovereign providence and His moral approval must be maintained.
Nor does Christian providence require us to believe that human decisions are meaningless.
The Scriptures consistently hold men accountable for their choices. They call us to repentance, obedience, prayer, and faithful action. The same Apostle who declares that all things work together for good also commands Christians to resist evil and pursue righteousness.
Providence does not abolish responsibility.
Neither does it abolish grief.
Our Lord Himself wept at the tomb of Lazarus, though He knew that He would shortly call His friend from the grave.
If the incarnate Son of God could weep in the presence of death, surely His ministers need not pretend that death is something other than an enemy.
Christian faith does not demand that we cease to mourn.
It demands that we mourn as those who possess hope.
Must Every Sorrow Have an Explanation?
Here we arrive at what may be the most difficult question raised by Romans 8:28.
Does God promise that every individual tragedy will eventually produce some recognizable good?
Or does Paul mean that all things, taken together, remain subject to God’s eternal purpose?
I believe the context strongly favors the latter.
We may sometimes recognize a particular good that has emerged from suffering. A man may discover humility through illness. A family may be reconciled following a crisis. A Christian may grow in patience, charity, or dependence upon God through circumstances he would never have chosen.
These things happen, and we may rightly give thanks for them.
But what of the suffering that appears to produce no such result?
What of the child who dies before reaching adulthood? What of the faithful wife who watches her husband decline through years of illness? What of the innocent victim whose life is destroyed by another man’s wickedness?
Are we obliged to search for some hidden benefit that will justify these tragedies?
I do not believe so.
Indeed, such an approach can become pastorally cruel.
Imagine telling grieving parents that the death of their child must have occurred so that some greater good could be accomplished. Even if the speaker intends to offer comfort, he risks presenting God as one who treats human suffering as a mere instrument for achieving some other objective.
But Romans 8:28 does not require us to make such a claim.
Paul does not promise that every sorrow will be explained within the limits of our earthly understanding.
He promises that God’s purpose for those who love Him remains secure.
There is an enormous difference.
The Christian may go to his grave without understanding why certain things were permitted to happen.
He may never see the earthly good that he once hoped would emerge from his suffering.
But his ignorance does not imply that God has lost control.
Nor does the absence of an explanation imply the absence of divine love.
The God who governs history has not promised to disclose every detail of His providence to us.
He has promised something greater.
He has given us His Son.
We Do Not Know, and Yet We Know
One of the most striking features of Romans 8 is the contrast between verses 26 and 28.
In verse 26, Paul acknowledges that we do not know what we should pray for as we ought.
Two verses later, he declares:
“And we know.”
The contrast deserves our attention.
We do not always know what to ask of God.
We do not always know what outcome would be best.
We do not always understand why our prayers appear to go unanswered, or why circumstances unfold in ways contrary to everything we had hoped.
Yet there is something we do know.
We know that God is faithful.
We know that His purposes cannot be overthrown.
We know that the One who raised Jesus Christ from the dead has not abandoned those whom He has called.
And we know that the final destiny of the Christian is not determined by the accidents, injustices, or tragedies of this present age.
It is determined by the God who has called us to Himself.
This is not ignorance masquerading as faith.
It is faith recognizing the limits of human knowledge while resting upon the revealed character of God.
There is no contradiction in saying, “Lord, I do not understand what You are doing, but I know who You are.”
Indeed, that may be among the purest expressions of Christian trust.
The Promise Is Greater Than Survival
We must also remember that Romans 8 does not conclude with verse 28.
Paul continues toward one of the most magnificent declarations in all of Scripture.
He asks who shall separate us from the love of Christ.
Tribulation? Distress? Persecution? Famine? Nakedness? Peril? Sword?
Notice that he does not deny the possibility of any of these things.
He does not promise that the Christian will escape persecution or survive the sword.
Instead, he declares that none of them can separate us from the love of God which is in Christ Jesus our Lord.
This is the true scope of the promise.
The Christian may lose his possessions, his health, his reputation, his freedom, and even his earthly life.
But he cannot be separated from Christ by any of these things.
Death itself, the great enemy of mankind, cannot finally triumph over those who belong to the risen Lord.
Here the Christian understanding of providence reaches beyond every merely earthly calculation.
The promise of Romans 8:28 is not that we shall always survive.
It is that we shall not finally perish.
For the God who calls us is the God who raises the dead.
The Certainty of the Christian Hope
There is something deeply reassuring about the words with which Paul begins this verse.
“And we know.”
Not “we suspect.”
Not “we hope that circumstances will improve.”
Not “we believe that someday everything will make sense.”
We know.
The certainty does not arise from our ability to interpret the circumstances of life. It arises from the character of the God who governs them.
The Christian does not need to discover a hidden blessing behind every sorrow in order to trust divine providence.
He does not need to pretend that evil is good, that injustice is acceptable, or that death is anything other than an enemy.
He needs only to remember that none of these things possesses ultimate authority.
God does.
And the God who governs all things is the same God who, in the fullness of time, took upon Himself our humanity, suffered under Pontius Pilate, was crucified, dead, and buried, and rose again on the third day.
The Resurrection is our assurance that suffering and death do not have the final word.
Christ does.
Romans 8:28, therefore, is not a promise that every tragedy will eventually make sense to us. It is the declaration that no tragedy, however terrible, can overthrow the eternal purpose of God.
We may not understand the road upon which He leads us.
We may not understand the burdens He permits us to carry.
We may not even live to see the good toward which His providence is working.
But we know the One who holds eternity in His hands.
And that is enough.
Before the Church can rise in power, she must first kneel in trembling.
The Rev. Dr. Ronald Moore is an Anglican priest, theologian, historian, and writer known for his essays on faith, tradition, and culture, as well as his ministry across the United States
Comments