jQuery Slider

You are here

Scottish Episcopal Church clergy rebel after 'divisive' appointment of bishop to conservative diocese

Scottish Episcopal Church clergy rebel after 'divisive' appointment of bishop to conservative diocese

By Harry Farley
Jan 5, 2018

A major row is erupting in the Scottish Episcopal Church (SEC) with half the paid clergy in one region rebelling over the appointment of their new bishop.

A letter to bishops of the Anglican SEC on Friday accused them of fostering 'disquiet and division' by nominating Canon Anne Dyer, the first female bishop in the SEC who is also strongly in favour of gay marriage, to be bishop of the largely conservative Diocese of Aberdeen and Orkney.

The general synod of the Scottish Episcopal Church met in Edinburgh in June and passed a resolution changing its teaching on marriage.

Dyer is now being urged to step down from her promotion with clergy protesting her appointment.

Two senior clergy have already quit over the issue and the letter threatens that 'others are considering similar action' in a diocese that is already struggling to fill a number of empty posts across its 41 churches.

It comes after the failure of the normal nomination process where church members within the diocese failed to name the required minimum of three candidates. The other bishops in the SEC then took over the process and nominated Dyer, but according to the protesters failed to consult clergy or churchgoers in the diocese first.

The protest letter, seen by Christian Today, is signed by seven stipendiary priests, half the clergy in the struggling northern diocese, which was the only one of the SEC's seven dioceses to reject the proposals to change its teaching on marriage, as well as several non-ordained senior churchgoers.

It accuses the bishops of being 'divisive and also disrespectful' by failing to appoint someone conservative clergy would agree with.

'There is now widespread disquiet and unhappiness within the Diocese,' a statement from the signatories says. 'Whatever the cause there is now pain, unease and division in a Diocese which had been largely united in its perception of what it needs from its Bishop now and in the years ahead.'

The clergy also note that Dyer does not drive a car and so would find it difficult to visit the very rural parishes, including on the islands of Orkney and Shetland.

The letter insists it is not a protest about women's ordination or gay relationships in the Church and stresses it is not a personal attack on Dyer but rather on 'the manner in which the appointment was carried out'.

Canon John Walker, synod clerk for the diocese and a spokesman for the signatories, told Christian Today the issue had been made worse because clergy had been blocked from meeting with Canon Dyer.

'That has pushes us into the position where we have had to deal with it in this way,' he said.

Asked about the calls for her to quit, he said: 'We would like to have a meeting with Canon Anne. We would also like for the diocese to have a vote on her election. If neither of those requests are possible then we would ask her to withdraw her position.'

He added: 'Our Church is committed to being an inclusive Church. We would hope the diversity of the Aberdeen diocese would be reflected in the bishop that was chosen for us.

'For the bishops to act in the way and appoint a bishop who is on the opposite side of the argument raises the question whether they are truly committed to a diverse and inclusive Church.'

It comes after the Dean of the Diocese, Dr Emsley Nimmo, and Canon Ian Ferguson from the Cathedral Chapter in Aberdeen, both quit in November accusing the Church of being 'not only insensitive but disrespectful'.

Last year the Scottish Episcopal Church became the first Anglican Church in the UK to permit gay weddings, removing its understanding of marriage as being between 'one man and one woman'. Now clergy can opt in to a register to carry out same-sex weddings if they want to.

A spokeswoman for the Scottish Episcopal Church said: 'We are aware that a letter has been sent to members of the College of Bishops and the Bishop-Elect, however at this point we are unable to make any comment.'


Row breaks out over the appointment of the north and north-east's first female bishop
Controversy has been sparked by the appointment of Rev Canon Anne Dyer

by Stephen Walsh
January 6, 2018

A row has broken out over the appointment of the north and north-east's new anglican bishop.

Canon Anne Dyer, the first female to be elected to the role in the Scottish Episcopal Church, was chosen to represent the Aberdeen and Orkney diocese in November.

However, her appointment has sparked controversy among some members of the clergy who were opposed to her selection and who claim their views were ignored by the decision-making panel of bishops.

Canon Dyer's opponents, who say the issue is causing "disquiet and division", have also argued she is not suitable for the role due to her reportedly being unable to drive, given the large rural area much of the diocese encompasses.

The group -- who insists their opposition is not based on her gender -- has also accused the bishop-elect of refusing to meet with them prior to her taking on the position.

An open letter has been sent to Canon Dyer and the College of Bishops which has been signed by seven members of the stipendiary, or paid, clergy and eight other priests or diocese representatives from across the north and north-east.

In the letter, the group calls on the bishop-elect to withdraw her acceptance or for a further decision to be taken on her appointment by the electoral synod of the diocese.

A spokesman for the group said: "The number who have signed the open letter represent 50% of the stipendiary clergy of the diocese.

"The lay people who have signed are members of the standing committee and the warden of the lay readers.

"No attempt has been made to find further signatures, but it is known that there are many more people concerned about the process to which we are objecting than have had the opportunity to sign."

The Yorkshire-born cleric will be the first ever woman to take up the role in Scotland since the creation of the church in the 1580s.

Women have only been considered for election since 2003.

Canon Dyer -- who will leave her post as Rector of Holy Trinity church, Haddington -- will be consecrated on March 1 and will take over from the Rt Rev Dr Robert Gillies, who retires from the post after nine years.

A spokeswoman for the Scottish Episcopal Church said "We are aware that a letter has been sent to members of the College of Bishops and the Bishop-Elect, however at this point we are unable to make any comment."

Get a bi-weekly summary of Anglican news from around the world.
comments powered by Disqus
Letter to the Churches, text and commentary
Prayer Book Alliance
Trinity School for Ministry

Land of a Thousand Hills Coffee

Drink Coffee

Do Good

Sustainable Ministry

Coffee, Community, Social Justice


Go To Top