She Walked the Emmaus Road but Left Out the Part Where Jesus Opened the Scriptures
Mullally never defines the gospel

By David W. Virtue, DD www.virtueonline.org November 19, 2026
Give the Archbishop of Canterbury her due. Her presidential address to the newly elected General Synod on Tuesday was more candid than most of what has come from Lambeth in recent decades. She said she did not want to offer "a picture-postcard image" of the Church of England. She wanted the Synod to "see things as they are." For an institution that has spent years issuing upbeat strategy papers while its pews emptied, that is not nothing.
She was candid about the clergy too. "Too many clergy are struggling," she said, describing priests stretched across several parishes, buried under administration and isolated. Then came the line that drew applause from the chamber: clergy, churches and parishes "are not burdens to manage: they are the treasure of the Church of England."
Anyone who has followed the Save the Parish movement knows why the members clapped. For a decade, money and energy in the national Church flowed toward diocesan schemes, central initiatives and new layers of management, while the parish priest, the one who actually baptizes the babies, visits the dying and buries the dead, was handed another benefice and told to be resilient. If Sarah Mullally means what she said, it is a welcome correction.
She was right as well to tell the Government to "think again" about VAT on church repairs. Parishes with leaking roofs, failing organs and no lavatories should not be taxed for the privilege of keeping England's architectural inheritance standing.
So far, so good. The penny has dropped. But only halfway.
Symptoms Without a Diagnosis
Everything the Archbishop described is a symptom. The priest with five parishes is not the cause of the Church of England's decline; he is its result. The roof cannot be fixed because there are too few people in the pews to pay for it. The clergyman is isolated because the congregations that once surrounded him have aged and thinned.
At no point did the archbishop ask the question any physician asks first: why? Why did the people leave? Why has Sunday attendance been falling for half a century, through every reorganization, every vision statement and every strategy for growth?
The answer is not primarily financial, and it is not a mystery. Churches that preach the Bible plainly, call people to repentance and faith, and expect conversion tend to hold their ground or grow. Churches that offer a mild spirituality with no edges tend to shrink. Canadian sociologist David Haskell's study of mainline Protestant congregations found exactly that: theology predicted growth more reliably than programs did. The Church of England's own healthy congregations, many of them evangelical, are living proof.
An address that names the exhaustion but not its source offers a care plan for a patient whose illness has not been identified.
The Emmaus Road, Abridged
The archbishop chose Luke 24 as her text, describing the two disciples on the road "sharing their hopes, questions, and worries" as the risen Jesus walks beside them. She invited the Synod to consider how it, too, might "walk together in the way of Christ."
It is a lovely image. It is also half the story.
Luke tells us what Jesus actually did on that road. He did not simply accompany. He rebuked: "O fools, and slow of heart to believe all that the prophets have spoken" (Luke 24:25). Then, "beginning at Moses and all the prophets, he expounded unto them in all the scriptures the things concerning himself" (24:27). When the two later reflected on what had happened, they did not say their hearts burned because someone walked with them. Their hearts burned "while he opened to us the scriptures" (24:32).
Take the rebuke and the Bible study out of Emmaus and you are left with a pleasant afternoon stroll. That, in a sentence, is the theology of accompaniment that now governs the Church of England: Jesus as companion, not teacher; presence without proclamation; walking without arriving.
John 17, Half-Read
From Emmaus the Archbishop moved to the Upper Room. Christ, she said, "did not pray for us to agree about everything, but he did pray for us to be one."
Nobody believes Christians must agree about everything. Anglicans have argued over vestments, music and the placement of the Holy Table for five centuries and survived. The question is not whether disagreement exists but what kind it is.
Read the whole prayer. "Sanctify them through thy truth: thy word is truth" (John 17:17). Jesus prays for those who will believe "through their word" (17:20), the apostolic word. The unity of John 17 is unity in the truth, not unity in place of it.
When the archbishop spoke of Synod members "whose convictions may differ deeply," everyone in the chamber knew what she meant: Living in Love and Faith, the Prayers of Love and Faith for same-sex couples, and the pressure for standalone services of blessing. These are not quarrels about the color of the altar frontal. They concern what Scripture teaches about marriage, sexual holiness and repentance, which are precisely the things Jesus's prayer says sanctify his people. To frame them as differences that a shared walk can absorb is the old "two integrities" settlement dressed in devotional language.
The Anglican Communion has already rendered its verdict on that settlement. After Mullally's appointment was announced in October 2025, GAFCON's leaders declared that Canterbury could no longer serve as the Communion's focus of unity, and the Global South has long said much the same. These are provinces that claim the large majority of the world's practicing Anglicans. Their departure did not merit a sentence. A speech about walking together said nothing about those who have already walked away, or why.
The Missing Word
The archbishop closed by urging the Synod to have "the courage to be deeply confident in the gospel and its saving power."
Fine words. But nowhere in the address did she say what the gospel is.
There was no sin to be saved from. No cross, no atonement, no repentance, no new birth, no judgment, no Lord who commands as well as comforts. The risen Jesus appeared, but only as a fellow traveler. Confidence in an undefined gospel is confidence in a word.
The Apostle Paul managed the definition in a single sentence: "I declare unto you the gospel... how that Christ died for our sins according to the scriptures; and that he was buried, and that he rose again the third day according to the scriptures" (1 Corinthians 15:1-4). A presidential address can surely spare one.
This is not pedantry. A Church that cannot say what its gospel is will not persuade anyone to believe it, will not know what to defend when it is contradicted, and will not know what it is uniting around when it calls for unity. The vagueness is not a gap in the speech. It is the illness.
Trust Is Earned, Not Requested
The archbishop rightly named safeguarding as "an essential priority" and spoke of the need for trust and accountability. "As bishops and clergy," she said, "we want to serve with confidence and to be trusted to lead."
Two years after the Makin review and the resignation of Justin Welby, that sentence has the order backwards. Trust follows accountability; it does not precede it. The people in the pews, and the survivors who waited decades to be heard, will extend trust when they see bishops held to account, not when bishops ask for it.
Managing the Decline
Taken as a whole, the address is a competent piece of institutional pastoral care. Wellbeing for exhausted clergy. VAT relief for leaking roofs. Process for safeguarding. Accompaniment for the divided. Each has its place. None will fill a pew.
The Church of England does not chiefly lack money, staff or morale. It lacks a clear word. It has the buildings, the history, the liturgy and, in the Book of Common Prayer and the Thirty-Nine Articles, a doctrinal inheritance as rich as any in Christendom. What it has lost is the nerve to say plainly what that inheritance teaches.
The two disciples did not turn around that night and walk seven miles back to Jerusalem because a sympathetic stranger had kept them company. They went back because the Scriptures had been opened and they had recognized the Lord.
Walk together, by all means. But the Emmaus Road leads back to Jerusalem only when someone opens the Book.
David W. Virtue, DD, is founder and managing editor of VirtueOnline. His writings can be found at www.virtueonline.org, where you can subscribe to receive his free biweekly VIEWPOINTS. His Substack on the Middle East can be viewed here: davidvirtue2.substack.com




Comments