top of page

Removing One Female Bishop Won’t Fix a Church

10 hours ago
8 min read

The crisis in Canterbury is not merely about who occupies the archiepiscopal throne. It is about whether the Church of England still possesses the faithfulness necessary to lead the Anglican Communion


Christ Driving the Money Changers from the Temple, by El Greco
Christ Driving the Money Changers from the Temple, by El Greco

By The Rev. Dr. Ronald Moore The Southern Anglican November 15, 2026


A bishop recently made a declaration that caught my attention. He affirmed that he would remain Anglican regardless of a vacant See of Canterbury, the fragmentation of North American Anglicanism, or the uncertain future of our ecclesiastical institutions. He would remain faithful to the English patrimony of his forefathers and continue praying for an Anglican rebirth.

The phrase that interested me was “a vacant See of Canterbury.”

The Church of England, of course, does not consider Canterbury vacant. Sarah Mullally occupies the archiepiscopal office. She is recognized by the established Church as its Archbishop of Canterbury.

But for those of us who maintain the historic understanding of Holy Orders, the matter is considerably more complicated.

The Church has no authority to alter the sacramental constitution of the apostolic ministry. The episcopate is not an office that the Church may redefine according to the prevailing convictions of society. It is an order received from the Apostles, entrusted to the Church for preservation and transmission.

Consequently, those who reject the possibility of women’s episcopal ordination cannot recognize Mullally as a bishop in the sacramental sense, whatever legal or institutional office she may occupy.

From that perspective, Canterbury is indeed vacant.

But suppose tomorrow the Church of England appointed a properly consecrated male bishop to Canterbury. Would that solve the problem?

Not remotely.


The Difference Between a Vacant See and a Compromised Church

A vacant episcopal see can be filled. A compromised church cannot be repaired merely by filling an office.

This distinction is essential because the crisis confronting the Church of England extends far beyond the question of women’s ordination.

Indeed, reducing the problem to that single issue risks misunderstanding the nature of the crisis altogether.

The ordination of women to the priesthood and episcopate represents, in the traditional Anglican understanding, a departure from apostolic order. But the underlying problem is the assumption that the Church possesses authority to alter what it has received.

Once that assumption is accepted, the question ceases to be what the Apostles taught and becomes what the contemporary institution is prepared to approve.

And that is an entirely different understanding of the Church.

Article XX of the Thirty-Nine Articles establishes the proper boundary of ecclesiastical authority:

“The Church hath power to decree Rites or Ceremonies, and authority in Controversies of Faith: And yet it is not lawful for the Church to ordain any thing that is contrary to God’s Word written.”

The Church possesses authority. It does not possess sovereignty over divine revelation.

It may teach the faith, defend the faith, explain the faith, and apply the faith to new circumstances. It may not manufacture a different faith and then demand that Christians accept the innovation as apostolic Christianity.

The Church is a steward, not an owner.


The Problem Is Larger Than Holy Orders

Women’s ordination is not the only issue confronting the Church of England.

There are profound questions concerning the authority of Holy Scripture, the doctrine of marriage, sexual morality, the discipline of clergy, and the relationship between Christian revelation and contemporary social expectations.

The controversies surrounding the blessing of same-sex relationships are particularly revealing.

The Church has historically understood marriage as the lifelong union of one man and one woman, instituted by God and bearing theological significance beyond the preferences of the individuals involved.

Yet contemporary ecclesiastical debates frequently proceed as though the fundamental question were whether the Church can devise a sufficiently accommodating pastoral arrangement.

But pastoral care cannot be separated from doctrinal truth.

We are commanded to love our neighbors. We are not authorized to redefine holiness in order to make that love more acceptable to the surrounding culture.

Christ Himself declared:

“If you love Me, keep My commandments.” (John 14:15, NKJV)

Love and obedience are not enemies.

Nor is this simply a question of sexual morality. It concerns the larger issue of whether Scripture exercises authority over the Church or whether the Church exercises authority over Scripture.

The distinction is decisive.

When ecclesiastical leaders begin treating biblical teaching as material to be negotiated rather than truth to be received, the crisis is no longer confined to one disputed doctrine.

It has reached the foundation of ecclesiastical authority itself.


An Institution Can Survive After Its Faith Has Been Abandoned

One of the most uncomfortable truths in Church history is that institutional survival does not necessarily demonstrate spiritual fidelity.

A church may retain its cathedrals, vestments, endowments, legal privileges, historic titles, and elaborate ceremonies while abandoning the theological convictions that once gave those things their meaning.

The buildings remain. The offices remain. The ceremonies continue.

But continuity of administration is not the same as continuity of faith.

Consider the warning delivered to the Church at Ephesus in Revelation.

Christ commended its works, perseverance, and rejection of false apostles. Yet He also declared:

“Nevertheless I have this against you, that you have left your first love.” (Revelation 2:4, NKJV)

And His warning was unmistakable. Unless the church repented, He would remove its lampstand.

Notice that Christ did not promise to preserve an ecclesiastical institution merely because it possessed an honorable history.

The Church belongs to Him.

Its authority is derived from Him.

Its continued existence as a faithful witness depends upon its obedience to Him.

The Church at Sardis received an equally sobering judgment:

“I know your works, that you have a name that you are alive, but you are dead.” (Revelation 3:1, NKJV)

A name is not enough.

Neither is an ancient pedigree.

And neither is possession of an episcopal throne that has stood for centuries.


Canterbury Is Not Anglicanism

Here we encounter a distinction that Anglicans must recover.

The Archbishop of Canterbury did not create Anglicanism. Nor does the Archbishop possess authority comparable to the universal jurisdiction claimed by the Bishop of Rome.

Canterbury’s historic position arose through the development of the English Church and, subsequently, the worldwide relationships that produced the Anglican Communion.

The Archbishop became a focus of unity, a primus inter pares, among Anglican bishops.

That position deserves historical respect.

But it does not confer an unconditional right to lead.

The authority of Canterbury has always depended, at least morally and theologically, upon the faithful exercise of the office.

If the institution occupying Canterbury departs from apostolic faith and order, Anglicans are not obligated to follow that departure merely because it originates from an ancient ecclesiastical center.

We are Anglicans because we stand within the received Christian faith expressed through the English ecclesiastical and liturgical patrimony.

We are not Anglicans because we pledge unconditional allegiance to whoever happens to occupy Lambeth Palace.

The distinction matters enormously.

Indeed, the English Reformers themselves insisted that the Church of England was not a newly invented church. They understood their work as the restoration of the historic English Church to the authority of Scripture and the faith of the ancient Church.

The institution was to be judged by the faith, not the faith by the institution.

That principle remains valid today.


Would a Male Archbishop Restore Canterbury?

Let us suppose, however unlikely the circumstances, that the next Archbishop of Canterbury were a man validly consecrated in the historic episcopate.

From the traditional sacramental perspective, the immediate question concerning the occupant of the see would be resolved.

But the Church of England would still face the consequences of decades of doctrinal and ecclesiastical decisions.

Women would continue to occupy priestly and episcopal offices. The Church would continue to wrestle with the consequences of its innovations concerning marriage and sexuality. Questions concerning biblical authority, discipline, and the nature of the ordained ministry would remain.

A new archbishop could not erase those realities simply by taking office.

A valid bishop does not automatically produce a faithful church.

Nor would a change in leadership constitute repentance.

Repentance requires acknowledging wrongdoing, turning away from it, and seeking restoration.

It is not merely a change in administrative direction.

John the Baptist warned the religious leaders of his day:

“Therefore bear fruits worthy of repentance.” (Matthew 3:8, NKJV)

That command applies to ecclesiastical institutions no less than to individuals.

If the Church of England were genuinely to recover its historic apostolic identity, it would require more than appointing an orthodox archbishop.

It would require the reversal of innovations contrary to apostolic faith and order, the restoration of doctrinal discipline, and a renewed submission to the authority of Holy Scripture.

It would require institutional repentance.

And repentance is considerably more difficult than replacing an officeholder.


The Church Does Not Belong to Canterbury

None of this means that we should desire Canterbury’s permanent destruction or abandonment.

Quite the opposite.

I would welcome the genuine restoration of the Church of England to apostolic faith and order. And should such a restoration occur, I would welcome Canterbury’s return to its historic position as a center of Anglican unity.

Its ancient place in our ecclesiastical inheritance need not be erased.

But neither may its history be used to excuse its present departures from that inheritance.

The distinction between the Church of England as a historical institution and Anglicanism as a theological and ecclesiastical tradition must be maintained.

An institution can retain its legal identity while ceasing to represent faithfully the tradition from which it arose.

And when that happens, the responsibility for preserving the inheritance falls upon those who remain faithful to it.

That is not the invention of a new Anglicanism.

It is the preservation of the old.

The faithful Anglican does not need to abandon the Book of Common Prayer, the historic episcopate, the creeds, the sacraments, or the English Christian patrimony because Canterbury has lost its way.

Nor must he pretend that institutional loyalty requires doctrinal surrender.

The Church’s unity is not secured by obedience to an ecclesiastical office regardless of what that office teaches.

True Christian unity is unity in Christ and in the truth He has revealed.

As St. Paul admonished Timothy:

“Hold fast the pattern of sound words which you have heard from me, in faith and love which are in Christ Jesus.” (2 Timothy 1:13, NKJV)

That is the task entrusted to every generation.

Not to invent a new faith.

Not to modify the old faith until it becomes acceptable to the age.

But to receive, preserve, teach, and transmit what has been entrusted to us.


The Way Back Is Repentance

There is a temptation, when confronting an ecclesiastical crisis, to imagine that replacing the person at the top will resolve the underlying problems.

Remove this bishop. Appoint another. Change the leadership. Issue a new statement.

And perhaps things will improve.

But the Church is not merely an organization whose problems can be resolved through changes in management.

It is the Body of Christ, called to holiness, truth, and obedience.

Its restoration cannot be accomplished through administrative rearrangement alone.

The Lord’s message to the churches in Revelation was not that they should improve their public relations or appoint more effective administrators.

It was that they should repent.

To the Church at Ephesus, Christ commanded:

“Remember therefore from where you have fallen; repent and do the first works.” (Revelation 2:5, NKJV)

That remains the path of restoration.

If Canterbury is ever to resume its historic place as a faithful center of Anglican unity, the Church of England must do more than place a validly consecrated man upon the archiepiscopal throne.

It must recover the faith that throne was established to serve.

Until then, faithful Anglicans must continue the work entrusted to them: preaching the Gospel, administering the sacraments, maintaining apostolic order, teaching the Scriptures, and worshipping Almighty God in spirit and in truth.

We need not abandon our Anglican inheritance simply because an institution has abandoned its responsibility to preserve it.

And we need not surrender hope that repentance and restoration remain possible.

But we must never confuse hope with denial.

Removing one female bishop might resolve the immediate question of who occupies Canterbury. It will not resolve the question of what the Church of England has become.

A vacant see needs a bishop.

A fallen church needs repentance.

And no amount of ecclesiastical administration can substitute for either.

The Rev. Dr. Ronald Moore’s Substack is “The Southern Anglican,” a platform where he writes and speaks on theology, history, and culture, calling the Church to faithfulness, reverence, and courage in a confused age



Comments


ABOUT US

In 1995 he formed VIRTUEONLINE an Episcopal/Anglican Online News Service for orthodox Anglicans worldwide reaching nearly 4 million readers in 204 countries.

CONTACT

570 Twin Lakes Rd.,
P.O. Box 111
Shohola, PA 18458
​

​

virtuedavid20@gmail.com

SUBSCRIBE FOR EMAILS

Thanks for submitting!

©2026 by Virtue Online.
Designed & development by Experyans

  • Facebook
bottom of page