APCK MUST DECIDE ISSUE OF UNITY WITH OTHERS
By David W. Virtue
www.virtueonline.org
6/22/2007
The Bishop of the Eastern States of the Anglican Province of Christ the King, (APCK) the Rt. Rev. Rocco A. Florenza has written a letter to his clergy and people declaring that "a state of genuine unity and full communion" now exists with the Anglican Church in America (ACA).
Bishop Florenza's unilateral action has neither been approved nor disapproved by the other bishops of the APCK, a denomination which stands at a crossroads.
The timing of this announcement comes as Archbishop Robert Sherwood Morse has said he will step down as the head of the Continuing Church body.
The election of his successor is scheduled for the end of June.
The staunchly Anglo-Catholic APCK was formed in 1977 following the Affirmation of St. Louis because of fundamental changes by the Episcopal Church at the 1976 Episcopal Convention in Minneapolis, Minnesota to accommodate new beliefs and practices i.e. the ordination of women to the priesthood and the adoption of the revisionist 1979 Prayer Book.
The Right Rev. George Langberg is President of the ACA. This Continuing Church body is a constituent member of the Traditional Anglican Communion (TAC) whose Archbishop is Australian-born John Hepworth.
In his letter, Florenza sharply criticized what he called "the brokenness of our witness for Christ as traditional Anglicans.
"Now, some thirty years after the Affirmation of St. Louis...the traditional Anglican expression in the U.S. has grown increasingly fragmented. At present between 20 and 40 groups calling themselves "Anglican" stand divided; and the few major groups whose roots are grounded in the Denver Consecrations, despite sharing communion and in some cases clergy, remain apart." Florenza said the divisions were "man-made."
"How is it possible to remain divided if we share the same apostolic origins, the same theology and the same Sacraments? Such divisions contradict the will of Christ [and] present a stumbling block to out work for Him in this world, and inflicts damage on our witness as traditional Anglican Christians."
Florenza then wrote, "It is in the interest of unity of the Body of Christ that the Diocese of Eastern States, Anglican Province of Christ the King, has renewed its commitment to ever-closer work with those who share the same origins, theology and sacraments."
Florenza then said as "your diocesan bishop I have pledged to increase our cooperation and fellowship with the Anglican Church in America (ACA), a respected body that has been in real and visible communion with this diocese and with the province. Therefore, I now declare openly a state of genuine unity and full communion with these our brothers and sisters who hold fast to the same eternal truths as do we."
A source told VOL. "Bishop Florenza is moving unilaterally toward unity with the ACA because he feels it is right and he has grown tired of the solitary status quo."
"If Florenza encounters opposition from his fellow APCK bishops to his agreement with the ACA, he has the option to move his entire diocese into the ACA," said the source. "Bishop Florenza's letter is a Godly challenge to the current direction of the APCK and is a much needed breath of fresh air and vitality."
Florenza's plea for Christian unity comes at a critical juncture in the life of the Anglican Communion. Realignment of North American Anglicanism is in full swing and continues to gain momentum.
In recent weeks four new "missionary" Anglican dioceses have formed in the U.S. including Bishop Martyn Minns for the Anglican Province of Nigeria (CANA), Bishop William Cox of the Anglican Province of the Southern Cone, Bishop-elect Bill Atwood of the Anglican Province of Kenya and Bishop-elect John Guernsey who will serve 26 congregations for the Anglican Province of Uganda.
All of them are members of the Anglican Communion Network led by Pittsburgh Bishop Bob Duncan who also heads Common Cause which includes bishops from the Anglican Communion Network, the Anglican Mission in the Americas (including the Anglican Coalition in Canada), the Convocation of Anglicans in North America, the Anglican Network in Canada, the Anglican Province of America, Forward in Faith North America and the Reformed Episcopal Church. They will hold their first-ever Common Cause Council of Bishops in Pittsburgh, PA, September 25-28.
END
DIOCESE OF THE EASTERN STATES
ANGLICAN PROVINCE OF CHRIST THE KING
The Rt. Rev. Rocco A. Florenza
Diocesan Bishop
A PASTORAL LETTER TO BE READ FROM THE PULPITS OF ALL PARISHES AND MISSIONS
June 21, 2007
To the clergy and people of the Diocese of the Eastern States:
Greetings in the Name of our Lord Jesus Christ! I write to you today On the Unity of Christ's Church.
On June 9th, 2007, the Diocese of the Eastern States concluded its annual synod. It was a time of learning, prayer, fellowship and, most importantly, communion. Gathered before the Altar the faithful of this diocese united in the celebration of the Eucharist, joined at that moment with all in the church that is holy, catholic and apostolic. The closing mass of this synod was an occasion of profound joy, yet tinged with sorrow over the brokenness of our witness for Christ as traditional Anglicans.
Now, some thirty years after the Affirmation of St. Louis and the consecration of four priests to the episcopacy by the Rt. Rev. Albert Chambers and other bishops, to continue the traditional Anglican expression in the United States, that witness, begun in great hope and fervent prayer, has grown increasingly fragmented. At present between 20 and 40 groups calling themselves "Anglican" stand divided; and the few major groups whose roots are grounded in the Denver Consecrations, despite sharing communion and in some cases clergy, remain apart. One may claim any number of reasons for these unhappy divisions, but they essentially are man-made.
The unity of divided humanity is the will of God. For this very reason the Father sent His Son, so that by dying and rising for us He might bestow on us the Spirit of love. Indeed the night before His sacrifice on the Cross, Jesus Himself prayed to the Father for His disciples and for all those who believe in Him, that they might be one, as He and the Father are one, in living communion.
This forms the basis of the duty and responsibility of those in the Body of Christ to foster reconciliation and unity.
Daily and during the course of our synod, faithful laity have repeatedly asked, "How is it possible to remain divided if we share the same apostolic origins, the same theology and the same Sacraments? What precisely is it that separates us?" In truth, such divisions contradict the will of Christ, presents a stumbling block to our work for Him in this world, and inflicts damage on our witness as traditional Anglican Christians,
A community truly centered in Christ present in the Sacrament cannot be closed in upon itself, as though it were somehow self-sufficient; rather it must strive for harmony with other catholic communities. Cooperation among all Christians incarnates the bond that unites them, and reveals to the world the servant hood of Christ.
It is in the interest of unity of the Body of Christ that the Diocese of the Eastern States, Anglican Province of Christ the King, has renewed its commitment to ever-closer work with those who share the same origins, theology and Sacraments. As a first step, I, your diocesan bishop have pledged to increase our cooperation and fellowship with the Anglican Church in America, a respected body that has been in real and visible communion with this diocese and with the province. Therefore, I now declare openly a state of genuine unity and full communion with these our brothers and sisters who hold fast to the same eternal truths as do we.
In the eyes of the world, cooperation among Christians is a form of common Christian witness and represents a means of evangelization commanded by Christ. Such cooperation based on our common faith, our common origin and our common sacraments is nothing less than a manifestation of Christ Himself.
The peace of the Lord be always with you.
Faithfully,
+ Rocco A. Florenza
| Poster | Thread |
|---|---|
| morrismpls | Posted: 2007/6/23 4:09 Updated: 2007/6/23 4:09 |
Home away from home ![]() ![]() Joined: 2004/1/4 From: Posts: 496 |
While I'm not sure I entirely applaud the method, I am glad that someone is finally trying to make another movement towards unity among the Continuing Anglicans.
|
| stmike | Posted: 2007/6/23 10:08 Updated: 2007/6/23 10:08 |
Quite a regular ![]() ![]() Joined: 2004/10/19 From: Plymouth, NH Posts: 63 |
Plymouth, NH
It is indeed inspiring and encouraging to see the bold leadership of Bishop Rocco Florenza of the APCK. Leadership on the subject of unity is precisely what is needed for the much desired unity to occur. Faithful Anglicans need to unite as soon as possible so as to respond to our Lord's call to eveangelism. There are many unchurched in America; there are lots of Episcopalians who are being abandoned by the leadership of the Episcopal Church as rapidly moves away from orthodoxy, so as to embrase some strange form of Modernism. More parishes need to be formed, etc. Unity between members of the APCK and the Anglican Church in America (ACA) makes much sense, as the two jurisdictions agree on the basics and are so very similar in the details (which are not really required for unity). May Bp. Florenza and all of the members of the APCK be richly blessed as they ponder the opportunities which lie before them. Yours in Christ's love, Dean Steward + |
| FrSam+ | Posted: 2007/6/23 11:25 Updated: 2007/6/23 11:25 |
Home away from home ![]() ![]() Joined: 2004/7/15 From: Posts: 555 |
To interject + Duncan at the end of this story doesn't make much sense to me.
I doubt if any bishop in the APCK will cotton to "ordained" females, be they "deacons" or "priest(ess)s." Once again in a story like this that holds so much promise with so many groups the 800 pound gorilla in the room rears it's ugly head. We can all track towards unity (and we should) but sooner or later this issue MUST be resolved if traditional and orthodox (not just conservative) Anglicans are to come together in a meaningful and powerful way. As long as Bishop Duncan insists on laying hands on women to "priest" them, most talks with truly orthodox Anglican bishops are dead in the water. I pray that all Anglican bishops who consider themselves "orthodox" will one day lay this innovation aside for the greater unity of the Church. Sam + |
| APBIDDLE | Posted: 2007/6/23 14:22 Updated: 2007/6/23 14:22 |
Not too shy to talk ![]() ![]() Joined: 2004/3/20 From: Franklin, TN Posts: 28 |
I suppose it is better than nothing, but unilateral action by a bishop/archbishop/equivalent has been a feature of the Continuing Church movement for decades. Whole diocese have awakened to find they now belong to a different CC. And yes, this is much less than a transfer, but there is at least a fair chance the the APCK leadership will not react with great enthusiasm.
|
| LoveTruth | Posted: 2007/6/23 17:11 Updated: 2007/6/23 17:11 |
Just popping in ![]() ![]() Joined: 2007/6/23 From: Pacific Northwest Posts: 2 |
Shame on you! You should know better. Posting only exerpts of Bishop Florenza's letter can lead to serious misunderstanding.
Is it a possibility that Bishop Florenza was stating facts already in evidence and not making a unilateral pronouncement? Please put this into proper context. The "source" may be trying to poison the waters before the APCK elects a new Archbishop. I invite the moderator to post the entire text of Bishop Florenza's letter on this blog so we may read it for ourselves without editorial comment. Anything else brings shame and does damage to the Body of Christ. For the record, I support prayerfully considered moves toward unity but I will not abide compromise in matters of doctrine. Kathleen Swan St Bartholomew's Woodinville, WA APCK |
| FrSam+ | Posted: 2007/6/23 17:14 Updated: 2007/6/23 17:14 |
Home away from home ![]() ![]() Joined: 2004/7/15 From: Posts: 555 |
Well said Kathleen.
Sam + |
| lapittengr | Posted: 2007/6/23 19:46 Updated: 2007/6/23 19:46 |
Home away from home ![]() ![]() Joined: 2004/1/21 From: Posts: 195 |
I should add to Kathleen's excellent observation the fact that -- at least as I understand it -- the APCK and the ACA had a series of discussions a few years back in which they determined there were neither theological nor doctrinal nor sacramental barriers between them. Indeed, I believe that the archbishop of the TAC publicly received communion from archbishop Morse at the time. (One of the APCK pilgrimages to Fond du Lac.)
I know of no details or previous official statement to the effect of such a APCK-ACA condord from a few years back (which doesn't prove they aren't there, simply that I don't know about them) -- this is merely layman's impression/understanding of what transpired and not any sort of official report or endorsement one way or the other -- I'm just recounting what appeared to me to be the universal sense of what was going on. So I think Kathleen is exactly right to urge restraint and charity and patience -- rather than a jurisdictional running around waving one's arms and shouting "schism". Maybe this was a unilateral move. Maybe the other APCK bishops will shrug and say "nothing new here, that's been the case for 3 years". Maybe something in between. Who knows. At the moment all folks have is this 2nd or 3rd hand report and commentary with partial quotations, possibly taken out of context, in a venue which has not been uniformly supportive of anglocatholics or the Continuing church. I suggest the sensible thing to do is not to make too big a deal of this, but to wait until if & when the full document is made available and wait until there has been an official response by the other APCK bishops as well as by the ACA... and, in the meantime, to focus energies prayerfully on building up of parishes and people, and helping Biblical Christians continue to escape - either into a Continuing church or elsewhere - the apostate shipwreck that is PECUSA of the last 30 years. And before anyone on the sidelines gets too worked up about the "speck" of jurisdictional shifts and realignments in the Continuum, perhaps they should make sure that they first blink out the "beam" of PECUSA's apostasy (if they're still in that jurisdiction.) Episcopal and jurisdictional disagreements within or between groups which share an orthodox Anglican theology pale in comparison to the rejection by a jurisdiction of the words and teaching of our Lord Himself. pax, LP |
| floppy2 | Posted: 2007/6/24 17:02 Updated: 2007/6/24 17:04 |
Just popping in ![]() ![]() Joined: 2006/1/12 From: Posts: 6 |
I was in attendance when His Excellency read his letter to the congregation.
Two points 1. His brother bishops are in agreement with the unity with the ACA. They are not ready to do has he has done or take the steps he has taken. 2. The Bishop knows that the APCK will die if these steps are not taken. He is opting for life. It is not a scismatic step..just one in a much needed direction. Pray for the election of the new Archbishop of the APCK. That man will be very important to the survival of this church and her mission on earth. Never have I seen such an opening of arms and a real yearning for unity in Christianity as a whole. Look very closely at what is going on in all denominations of the Christian faith. There is an understanding that we cannot work apart anymore. If we are to survive the evil onslaughts of reletivisim, homoeroticisim, abortion, islamofacisim and all the other satanic threats we face on, we have to work togeather. There is no other way now. Pray for the APCK, TLM Catholics, ACA, the ACC, eastern rite, the Orthodox church and all orthodox Christians all over the world. We all need one another now more than ever. Togeather we stand, divided we fall! Look at the big picture folks! B. Rickman |
| Fiona | Posted: 2007/6/25 3:13 Updated: 2007/6/25 3:13 |
Home away from home ![]() ![]() Joined: 2005/1/18 From: San Francisco Bay Area Posts: 1071 |
The real barrier to unity is that no bishop wants to give up his pointy hat.
That being said, I wish them all well and may even be in attendance to witness the passing of the baton on June 29, in Oakland, CA. Fiona |
| lapittengr | Posted: 2007/6/25 23:30 Updated: 2007/6/25 23:30 |
Home away from home ![]() ![]() Joined: 2004/1/21 From: Posts: 195 |
Thanks to DV for posting the text of +Florenza's letter.
To judge from the text of this letter itself, the ACA has already "been in real and visible communion with this diocese and with the province". This being the case, reaffirming it is not a unilateral or revolutionary decision, it is merely a restating of something to which the APCK & ACA as a whole have already agreed. The novelty in the letter, if any, would be that he has "pledged to increase our cooperation and fellowship with the Anglican Church in America". Yet this would appear -- again -- to be nothing more than a renewal of a commitment already made province-wide. Moreover, "cooperation" and "fellowship", per se, are hardly objectionable -- though one could posit ways of pursuing them which might create waves, this doesn't mean this letter intends such disruptive measures. Again, it seems to me that it is for the leadership of the APCK and the ACA to clarify this issue (and perhaps the ACC, which has some long-standing disagrements with and reservations about the ACA) -- blogged speculations are entertaining but, ultimately, of little or no consequence. What matters is what the ACA and APCK bishops think of this (which may be nothing more than "he's just reaffirmed what was already the case; what's all the fuss about?") -- they are the ones who have the authority and are making these decisions. pax, LP |
| Anonymous | Posted: 2007/6/26 19:58 Updated: 2007/6/26 19:58 |
|
James Provence will be the new archbishop. He was hand-picked by +Morse. He attended the APCK Theological College and later taught at it. His consecration was quite controversial as he is currently re-married. This caused a split with most of the southern diocese leaving the APCK and forming the Diocese of the Holy Cross. The DHC initially did not support clergy with annulments, but they now have several in their ranks.
|
|
| verumi | Posted: 2007/6/28 23:22 Updated: 2007/6/28 23:22 |
Just popping in ![]() ![]() Joined: 2007/6/28 From: Posts: 5 |
As if the APCK did not have enough trouble and controversy, today one of it's St. Joseph of Arimathea seminary instructors, Father William Martin, was found financially liable for defaming a former parisioner. The succesful litigant was awarded nearly $150,000. Father Martin has been forming their clergy for several years.
|
| lapittengr | Posted: 2007/6/29 22:36 Updated: 2007/6/29 22:36 |
Home away from home ![]() ![]() Joined: 2004/1/21 From: Posts: 195 |
Getting us back on topic, I noticed the following article about APCK/ACA/ACC fellowship in a past _Christian Challenge_ article, where Archbishop Morse (and Bishop Provence and Bishop Florenza) are depicted as being actively & fraternally hosting ACA and ACC bishops, and even sharing communion with the ACA bishops (the ACC bishops declining because of their long-standing differences with the ACA).
http://challengeonline.org/modules/articles/article.php?id=38 (second article down the page) I can't swear to all the details of that _CC_ report and its perspective (though I remember seeing all those bishops in Fond du Lac and the reception of communion); I don't know what may be going on "behind the scenes" with Bishop Florenza's letter or who's in the right or wrong or any of that. Nor do I mean to suggest otherwise. All I mean to point out is that the friendly relationship between the APCK and the ACA is not a novel suggestion -- whatever else may be going on. Whatever bumps there are on the way, I think there still is a real desire for unity among the genuine Continuing church anglocatholics. pax, LP |
| orgelmstr | Posted: 2007/7/2 12:14 Updated: 2007/7/2 12:14 |
Quite a regular ![]() ![]() Joined: 2004/9/29 From: CT Posts: 48 |
Yes, lapittengr, you're quite correct. There are a lot of things going on behind the scenes which very few people are aware of; like the fact that it's pretty much just one ++Individual preventing unity; and that many Bishops in the Contiuum want very badly to unite. Those who know Bishop Rocco well know that he is a straightforward, honest, faithful man, and he is not afraid to do what he considers right, even if it creates difficulty for himself. I was there at Fond du Lac and I know that Bishop was deeply hopeful for something that did not ultimately happen. Our Province has a stumbling block and we need to find a way over or around it. Bishop Rocco has much support on this!
Orgelmstr |
| frweber | Posted: 2009/10/31 1:40 Updated: 2009/10/31 1:40 |
Just popping in ![]() ![]() Joined: 2008/9/26 From: Posts: 11 |
And now, just two years later, +Florenza's hopped again--this time to the ACC. I suspect only an Archiepiscopate will suffice to hold him in place!
|

















